Application of RCD vs RLC Load Banks for Testing Generators and UPS Systems:

 

https://www.hatchpower.com/

Application of RCD vs RLC Load Banks for Testing Generators and UPS Systems:

The difference between RCD and RLC load banks is quite significant when testing generators or UPS systems, because each type imposes a different electrical characteristic on the system under test. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right one for your application:

---

⚙️ 1. RCD Load Bank

RCD = Resistive + Capacitive + Diode/Rectifier (or DC load)

(In some manufacturer contexts, RCD is shorthand for Resistive + Capacitive + Dynamic load, but in most UPS/generator testing, it implies a non-linear or rectified load.)

🔹 Characteristics:

• Simulates non-linear loads, such as those produced by rectifiers, inverters, and modern data center equipment (computers, UPS input stages, LED drivers, etc.).
• Draws current with harmonics, typically THDi between 25%–50%, similar to real-world IT or data center loads.
• Provides a realistic way to test how a UPS or generator handles harmonic currents, crest factor, and waveform distortion.

🔹 Use Case:

• UPS testing (especially double conversion systems) to verify performance under distorted load.
• Generator tests when evaluating AVR and governor stability with non-linear loads.

🔹 Pros:

• Simulates real-world power electronics loads.
• Evaluates true dynamic performance of the UPS inverter or generator AVR.
• Identifies harmonic handling and waveform distortion issues.

🔹 Cons:

• More expensive than purely resistive or RLC banks.
• Generates harmonics that can stress the test system.
• Power factor and current waveform are not adjustable independently.

---

⚙️ 2. RLC Load Bank

RLC = Resistive + Inductive + Capacitive

🔹 Characteristics:

• Provides linear loads with adjustable power factor (lagging, leading, or unity).
• Simulates loads such as motors, transformers, fluorescent lighting, and capacitor banks.
• Typically has sinusoidal current with negligible harmonic distortion.

🔹 Use Case:

• Generator load testing to check voltage regulation, stability, and power factor performance.
• UPS testing (for design verification) under different power factors without harmonics.

🔹 Pros:

• Adjustable power factor for comprehensive testing.
• No harmonic distortion (clean sinusoidal current).
• Useful for verifying true kVA capacity and reactive performance.

🔹 Cons:

• Does not simulate non-linear loads typical of modern data centers.
• Less representative of real-world IT or UPS loads.